Educational reference. Not legal advice. Rules and procedures vary by jurisdiction and change over time. Verified April 2026.
LawyerVsAttorney
Last verified April 2026
Affiliate disclosure: Some links on this page are referral links. We may earn a commission if you use a service. This does not affect our editorial assessment.

How to Find a Lawyer: Directories, State Bar Referrals, and What "Super Lawyer" Really Means

Finding a competent attorney starts with verifying they are actually licensed. Everything else -- directories, ratings, referrals -- comes after that first step.

Step 1: Verify the License

Every state bar publishes a free online member directory. Searching an attorney's name shows their current status (active, inactive, suspended, disbarred), their admission date, and any public disciplinary actions. This takes two minutes and should be done before any fee is paid.

State Bar Lawyer Referral Services

Most state bars operate a Lawyer Referral Service (LRS) that matches consumers with attorneys for low-cost initial consultations. The typical fee is $25-$75 for a 30-minute consultation. The ABA maintains a national directory of state bar LRS programmes. This is often the best starting point for people who do not have a personal network of attorneys to consult.

Major Directories: Honest Reviews

Martindale-Hubbell / Lawyers.com

Strong signal

The oldest legal directory, founded 1868. Peer-reviewed ratings (AV Preeminent is the highest). Owned by Internet Brands. The AV rating -- based on peer reviews by other attorneys and judges -- is a meaningful signal of reputation within the bar. Lawyers.com is the consumer-facing companion site with profile information and reviews.

Super Lawyers

Good signal with caveats

Published by Thomson Reuters. Selection: peer nomination + independent research + editorial review. Only 5% of attorneys per state receive the designation. However, listed attorneys pay for enhanced profile features -- the designation itself is editorially separate from the paid placement, but the commercial model is worth knowing. Rising Stars covers attorneys under 40.

Best Lawyers

Good signal

Peer nomination and voting by attorneys currently listed, plus editorial review. The selection process focuses on peer assessment of technical skill and professional conduct. One of the oldest peer-reviewed legal award organisations. Annual publication.

Avvo

Use with caution

Algorithm-generated ratings from 1.0-10.0 based on experience, disciplinary history, professional achievements, and industry recognition. The algorithm is opaque and has been criticised. Important note: Avvo's fee-sharing legal services product was found to violate ethics rules in NJ, PA, OH, and SC and was shut down. The free directory and Q&A forum still exist. Treat the rating as one data point.

FindLaw

Basic reference

Owned by Thomson Reuters. Directory with attorney profiles plus legal content. Good for basic contact information; less rigorous as a quality signal than Martindale or Super Lawyers.

Justia

Basic verification

Free directory. Aggregates bar admission data. Good for verification and basic profile information; less comprehensive than paid services.

LegalMatch

Lead-gen service

You describe your legal problem; attorneys in your area are notified and choose to respond. Attorneys pay for each lead. The model incentivises attorney response speed over quality matching. Use as a starting point, not a final decision.

Online Legal Services: LegalZoom, Rocket Lawyer, UpCounsel

Not directories in the traditional sense, but widely used as alternatives to hiring a private attorney:

How attorneys actually run their practice -- billing, case management, client communication -- is increasingly digital. For a sense of what the other side of the desk looks like, MyCasePricing.com covers practice management software that most mid-size firms now use.

Red Flags

First Meeting Checklist

BRING
  • Relevant documents (contracts, correspondence, filings)
  • Timeline of key events in writing
  • Names of other parties involved
  • Any deadlines you know about
  • Questions written out in advance
ASK
  • How many similar matters have you handled?
  • Who will handle my matter day-to-day?
  • What is the fee structure and billing increment?
  • What do you need from me to proceed?
  • What is a realistic outcome range?

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I verify an attorney is licensed?
Use your state bar's free online member directory. It shows current status, admission date, and any public disciplinary history. The lookup tool on this page links directly to each state's search page.
Are 'Super Lawyers' actually super?
Super Lawyers involves peer nomination and editorial review (only 5% of attorneys per state receive the designation). However, listed attorneys pay for enhanced profile placement. It is a reasonable signal but not a guarantee. Combine it with state bar verification and direct reference checks.
Do lawyers pay to be listed in directories?
For enhanced profiles and premium placement, yes. Basic listings are often free. The designation itself (e.g., Super Lawyers selection) is editorially separate from the paid placement, but the commercial model is worth understanding when evaluating signals.
Is an Avvo rating trustworthy?
Avvo ratings are algorithm-generated and have been criticised for opacity. Avvo's fee-sharing legal services product was found to violate ethics rules in NJ, PA, OH, and SC. The free directory and ratings still exist; treat as one signal, not a definitive endorsement.
Should I hire a lawyer from a TV ad?
High-volume personal injury firms that advertise heavily can be legitimate. Ask who handles your case day-to-day, what the trial vs settlement rate is, and how many active cases the handling attorney carries. Some advertising firms are case mills; others are well-run large practices.
What is the difference between a directory and a referral service?
A directory lists attorneys; you contact them directly. A lawyer referral service (LRS) -- typically state bar operated -- matches you with an attorney for a low-cost initial consultation ($25-$75). State bar LRS programmes are regulated; commercial services charge attorneys significantly more per lead.
What Lawyers Cost →Types of Lawyers →Disciplinary Rules →